HVAC-Talk: Heating, Air & Refrigeration Discussion banner
1 - 6 of 6 Posts

M3 Pete

· Registered
Joined
·
18 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
My compressor stopped working, and it's decision time. I have a 1980-era furnace that still works, and presumably the coil is that old too. The Carrier outdoor condenser is 10-15 years old, I think, I can't find any SEER rating on it.

The house is a 1982, one-story, slab on grade, 3000 foot house with significant southern exposure. Windows and sliding doors have been replaced with dual pane and all the energy saving stuff. Insulation is R19. Ducts are all metallic flex, with some thin insulation on them, in the attic, and they look like they were sloppily installed with fabric "duct" tape, so they probably leak pretty good.

I am in Southern California valley environment, with 90+ summers and about 15 days of 100+, and winters that dip below freezing about 15 nights a year, but mostly in 40-50s at night. We use our HVAC sparingly. In summer, we open the house at night and close it in the morning, and that keeps the AC off until mid afternoon or later. Heat is only used at night in the winter, days are usually warm enough not to need it.

Options are to (a) replace the outdoor unit with an R-22 freon condenser, (b) replace the outdoor unit and indoor coil with an R-410 freon unit, or (c) replace the whole shebang, the outdoor unit, the furnace and coil.

I have not looked into a heat pump, as I really don't know if that is feasible or warranted in my situation. I have not done a Manual J calc or anything like that. But if anyone has suggestions as to what I should do here, I'd appreciate them.

Is a 2-stage unit worthwhile in my situation? (A/C or furnace)
 
Discussion starter · #3 ·
The repair guy said the repair needed is only about $400 less than a new condenser unit, so it does not make sense to repair it.

Are there questions I should ask to better assess the cost-benefit?

Is there a website that explains all the different options? That might help me ask better questions.
 
13 SEER dry shipped condenser is a poor match to an existing 10 SEER coil.
I would only consider coil & condenser at MINIMUM & would seriously consider new furnace as well for a matched complete system.
You are in California- permits are required as well as 3rd party duct testing/equipment charge verification. Only way you can skate past duct testing is if they are asbestos.

IMO- unless you are staying in this house- replace the compressor (if in fact it needs it) & roll the dice. When the time comes- new equipment, ducts & Man J load calcs. Do it right.
 
Discussion starter · #6 ·
Long time no post. We actually managed to live without the AC last summer. Fortunately, our nights generally cool off, so we opened the house at night and closed up in the morning. Only about 10 days were miserable, as it was very hot and did not cool enough at night.

Anyway, I'm back to considering a replacement again, I don't want to roll the dice again this summer.

NEW INFO: I did some more research, and the AC appears to be ORIGINAL, meaning it's from 1982! How does this affect your advice? Replace the outdoor unit and indoor coil? Or still go with just the compressor?

Nobody commented on the two-stage. Are these worth the cost?
 
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.