Hello. I am a non-technical lady. Have a recently purchased house that will have mold remediation. This is going to be a long detailed post.
We have been advised by our consultant to have the HVAC system cleaned, the flex ducting replaced with rigid metal ducts, and consider installing an Aprilaire mechanical filter and an Ultra-Aire ventilating dehumidifier. Sounds simple on paper. In reality, it isn’t.
I have work proposals from 2 remediators regarding the work. Neither have proposed to follow the protocol provided to them. Instead, they have proposed their own plans, making my job much more complicated.
DUCTS:
One wants to remove all the insulation from the attic, encapsulate the attic floor with Johns Manville R-30 plastic wrapped batts, replace the ducts with rigid, replace the fiberglass insulation around the evaporator coil with Reflectix, and insulate the ducts with Reflectix.
His.agenda was to remove all the fiberglass from the system and the attic, which leads me down another trail. Why is fiberglass evil?
I saw online discussions of Reflectix and an article on Green Building Advisor?? refuting the claim of Reflectix as an insulation based on R value and other issues. Apparently you are supposed to use 3/4” spacers between the object and the Reflectix. They were saying that would be way too labor intensive and no contractor would use spacers. That information was from some years back. Not sure what the current consensus is on this item.
The 2nd contractor ignored the protocol and recommended rebuilding the duct system in a Manual-D design to exceed code (??) using a combination of rigid and flex ducting. Said he would air seal all duct work with 100 Year air sealant (what’s this?) and insulate with 3'' insulation (didn’t say what kind - whatever is std around here I guess) to prevent condensation. For the attic insulation, he will only replace what is damaged (I assume with the same type that is there - fiberglass batts).
I’ll pause here . . . .
I have never had to think about ductwork or insulation before. Now, I have to. I didn’t realize there are so many options and products out there - all with potential unintended consequences. I am severely sensitive to both mold and chemicals, so I have to understand risks involved.
Insulation needs to a) do it’s job, b) prevent condensation, c) not get moldy, d) not put toxic particles or fumes in the duct system or the house. What kind will be best?
DUCT QUESTIONS:
Rigid Metal Ducts
- some have lining of some sort, don’t they?
- my impression is the lining is bad for some reason
- the industry seems to favor flex ducting, but it’s impossible to completely remove mold, etc, so NO on flex
- why did the industry move away from rigid metal in the first place?
- are there downsides to rigid metal?
So, if I go with all rigid, what do I need to tell them? If there are lined and unlined or other variables, what do I need to specify beyond just rigid metal?
—————————
AIR PURIFICATION
The consultant recommended an Aprilaire mechanical filter and an Ultra-Aire ventilating dehumidifier. Recommended a pleated MERV 11 filter.
Once I looked into this, again, I discovered endless options and variables. The filters I am considering go up to MERV16. The higher the filter, the smaller and more volume of contaminants it removes. Higher rated filters will also strain the HVAC system. How high is too high? How do I figure this out?
VENTILATING DEHUMIDIFIER
One potential remediator offered a Honeywell DR dehumidifier and no ventilation. Said he no longer is a proponent of ventilators. Said he has seen the fresh air pulling too much moisture in to the filter and the filters getting moldy and contaminating the duct system. Something like that.
The absolute last thing I want is to create another mold problem.
Fresh air sounds like a good idea, but it’s contaminated with smoke and fragrance from neighbors, pesticide from the golf course 2 blocks over, etc. The filter isn’t going to remove VOCs or fumes, only particles.
Talk to me. Tell me what I need to know about filters, dehumidifiers, and ventilators. Help me understand if I really need a ventilator or if I should stick with just a filter and a dehumidifier.
How do these things affect the HVAC operation? Electric bills?
———————
ABOUT THE HOUSE
- One story, 1400 sf, about a 3” slab, 19 years old.
- HVAC unit and ducts are in a sufficiently vented, unconditioned attic
- located in the Southeast, hot 8 mths, humid year round
Okay. . . . Whew!!! That was a lot of information. Thank you in advance.
We have been advised by our consultant to have the HVAC system cleaned, the flex ducting replaced with rigid metal ducts, and consider installing an Aprilaire mechanical filter and an Ultra-Aire ventilating dehumidifier. Sounds simple on paper. In reality, it isn’t.
I have work proposals from 2 remediators regarding the work. Neither have proposed to follow the protocol provided to them. Instead, they have proposed their own plans, making my job much more complicated.
DUCTS:
One wants to remove all the insulation from the attic, encapsulate the attic floor with Johns Manville R-30 plastic wrapped batts, replace the ducts with rigid, replace the fiberglass insulation around the evaporator coil with Reflectix, and insulate the ducts with Reflectix.
His.agenda was to remove all the fiberglass from the system and the attic, which leads me down another trail. Why is fiberglass evil?
I saw online discussions of Reflectix and an article on Green Building Advisor?? refuting the claim of Reflectix as an insulation based on R value and other issues. Apparently you are supposed to use 3/4” spacers between the object and the Reflectix. They were saying that would be way too labor intensive and no contractor would use spacers. That information was from some years back. Not sure what the current consensus is on this item.
The 2nd contractor ignored the protocol and recommended rebuilding the duct system in a Manual-D design to exceed code (??) using a combination of rigid and flex ducting. Said he would air seal all duct work with 100 Year air sealant (what’s this?) and insulate with 3'' insulation (didn’t say what kind - whatever is std around here I guess) to prevent condensation. For the attic insulation, he will only replace what is damaged (I assume with the same type that is there - fiberglass batts).
I’ll pause here . . . .
I have never had to think about ductwork or insulation before. Now, I have to. I didn’t realize there are so many options and products out there - all with potential unintended consequences. I am severely sensitive to both mold and chemicals, so I have to understand risks involved.
Insulation needs to a) do it’s job, b) prevent condensation, c) not get moldy, d) not put toxic particles or fumes in the duct system or the house. What kind will be best?
DUCT QUESTIONS:
Rigid Metal Ducts
- some have lining of some sort, don’t they?
- my impression is the lining is bad for some reason
- the industry seems to favor flex ducting, but it’s impossible to completely remove mold, etc, so NO on flex
- why did the industry move away from rigid metal in the first place?
- are there downsides to rigid metal?
So, if I go with all rigid, what do I need to tell them? If there are lined and unlined or other variables, what do I need to specify beyond just rigid metal?
—————————
AIR PURIFICATION
The consultant recommended an Aprilaire mechanical filter and an Ultra-Aire ventilating dehumidifier. Recommended a pleated MERV 11 filter.
Once I looked into this, again, I discovered endless options and variables. The filters I am considering go up to MERV16. The higher the filter, the smaller and more volume of contaminants it removes. Higher rated filters will also strain the HVAC system. How high is too high? How do I figure this out?
VENTILATING DEHUMIDIFIER
One potential remediator offered a Honeywell DR dehumidifier and no ventilation. Said he no longer is a proponent of ventilators. Said he has seen the fresh air pulling too much moisture in to the filter and the filters getting moldy and contaminating the duct system. Something like that.
The absolute last thing I want is to create another mold problem.
Fresh air sounds like a good idea, but it’s contaminated with smoke and fragrance from neighbors, pesticide from the golf course 2 blocks over, etc. The filter isn’t going to remove VOCs or fumes, only particles.
Talk to me. Tell me what I need to know about filters, dehumidifiers, and ventilators. Help me understand if I really need a ventilator or if I should stick with just a filter and a dehumidifier.
How do these things affect the HVAC operation? Electric bills?
———————
ABOUT THE HOUSE
- One story, 1400 sf, about a 3” slab, 19 years old.
- HVAC unit and ducts are in a sufficiently vented, unconditioned attic
- located in the Southeast, hot 8 mths, humid year round
Okay. . . . Whew!!! That was a lot of information. Thank you in advance.